If contemporary Republicans did not seem at times so fixated on what other consenting adults did in the privacy of their homes, millions of these LGBT Americans might gladly vote Republican.
Many swing voters support many conservative planks but are very wary of how the Conservative movement has seemed increasingly censorious, since the Reagan and Bush Jr years, about consenting adults’ personal lives; and they fear America becoming a version of Margaret Atwood’s The Handmaid’s Tale.
So given that, go back to first Conservative principles, which used to be more inclusive:
Crime. Border. Economy. Unity.
Freedom.
Constitution.
The same theme — that a successful Presidential campaign is not a mirror reflection— should be applied to religious preferences as well. Don’t get mad at me yet — hear me out please.
I know many conservatives feel that they want a Christian America. I respect their deep faith.
But the Founders guaranteed freedom of conscience as the bedrock of our nation; and they insisted on having no established religion. A Christian state can be as tyrannical as an atheist one — see the Inquisition. And Christians, much as I respect them, do not own the idea of America, or of God. America is also Jewish, Hindu, Muslim, Buddhist and Atheist.
What I am trying to say here again is that a successful Presidential campaign cannot be a dream wish list, with all of your favorite items on it.
A winning Presidential campaign also cannot be a therapy session.
You won’t get everything you personally want or like, if you are going to actually win.
To win a Presidential campaign, whether you are on the right or the left, you cannot have all your personal preferences be expressed. You won’t have all your dreams come true.
To actually win, you cannot campaign on everything you want.
4/ Use surrogates
At this point, I am looking around for President Trump’s (or RFK Jr’s) surrogates. Where are they? “Surrogates” are campaign shorthand for people from all walks of life who go out to rallies, or onto the airwaves on online, and support their candidate, using the candidate’s talking points and making them their own. These can be actors, musicians, influencers, business leaders, “ordinary” people. Remember “Joe the Plumber”? But they all get a script and talking points; the campaign is supposed to manage them, and out they should go.
I see Megan Thee Stallion, twerking away for VP Harris. I don’t like it, but I see it. It’s there.
I see actors and tech bros and other elected officials speaking up for Harris/Walz. I see the UAW, all getting in line to express their support for Harris/Walz and to promote their campaign. There is VP Harris in navy, looking both slightly worried and unwell, and also somewhat Presidential. The stagecraft is solid.
Where are President Trump’s surrogates? Laura Loomer asked on X why the Trump campaign is pushing away people who want to help. Where are all the conservative commentators’ talking points? You may not think it is “original” or “authentic” to use talking points and surrogates, but a successful Presidential campaign sends daily talking points to sympathetic news outlets and to thousands of surrogates, so that everyone is “on message” with “the message of the day.” This messaging shifts according to news events, focus group reactions and polling.
Where, oh where, is this effort on behalf of MAGA?
The DNC predictably lined up their surrogate effort aggressively because their candidate is — well, just not very likable. So if you surround her with likable supporters, people can hold their noses and vote for her when they are alone in the voting booth.
To many millions of voters, believe it or not, Conservatives, President Trump’s policies are great but they don’t find the man himself very likable. He too urgently needs likable, admirable, diverse groups of people — country singers, athletes, entrepreneurs, tech guys, homemakers, teachers, cops, religious leaders — to stand up for him and to repeat his message.
This effort is so absent on the part of the RNC that it almost feels as if they do not want President Trump to win.
5/ Have a clear message in one place.
My last point is the most important: craft a clear message and put it in one place that is easy to find. A classic Presidential campaign boils down to a slogan or mission statement. “Change vs more of the same.” “Don’t change horses in midstream.” “Hope and change”. Or further back: “Where’s the Beef”? “Are you better off today than you were four years ago?” “It’s the Economy, Stupid.”
For this campaign, if I were consulting, I’d propose two:
“MAGA is for Everyone.”
And: “Bring Back Good Times.”
That’s it. Simple.
Repeat and repeat.
Building out from this core DNA of the message, should be a clear, succinct platform. Where is President Trump’s platform? And don’t refer me to a website. The platform should be five or six commitments, and no more than ten, that are easily accessible and that everyone will know by heart by November because they will be constantly repeated.
I had a delightful conversation with Dr Peter Navarro about President Trump’s campaign, but my heart sank a bit when he told me that the campaign had released a book, The New MAGA Deal: The Unofficial; Deplorables’ Guide to Donald Trump’s 2024 Policy Platform” with “a hundred actions in a hundred days.” That effort is much better than no visible platform at all, and I applaud Dr Navarro for putting it together; but respectfully if this is the main guide to the platform, it is way too much for anyone to summarize or quickly to check. (I had the same difficulty early on finding or hearing RFK Jr’s platform succinctly. His summaries have improved.)
If you search “Donald Trump 2024 Platform” a lot of nonsense and legacy media comment comes up on the critical first results page. The closest thing to a “platform” easily found, is “2024 Republican Party Platform” on the website of something called “The American Presidency Project.” It does not even say clearly that it is President Trump’s platform.
It is 20 items (too many). Ten of them are just great. I’d keep those and repeat them everywhere. Some are hard for non-MAGA-media consumers to understand (“End the weaponization of government against the American people”). Some are marginal or vague — what is “radical gender ideology”? I kind of know because I watch “MAGA media” but most of Americans won’t know. And some items are vague: bring the US “record levels of success.”
1. SEAL THE BORDER, AND STOP THE MIGRANT INVASION
- CARRY OUT THE LARGEST DEPORTATION OPERATION IN AMERICAN HISTORY
- END INFLATION, AND MAKE AMERICA AFFORDABLE AGAIN
- MAKE AMERICA THE DOMINANT ENERGY PRODUCER IN THE WORLD, BY FAR!
- STOP OUTSOURCING, AND TURN THE UNITED STATES INTO A MANUFACTURING SUPERPOWER
- LARGE TAX CUTS FOR WORKERS, AND NO TAX ON TIPS!
- DEFEND OUR CONSTITUTION, OUR BILL OF RIGHTS, AND OUR FUNDAMENTAL FREEDOMS, INCLUDING FREEDOM OF SPEECH, FREEDOM OF RELIGION, AND THE RIGHT TO KEEP AND BEAR ARMS
- PREVENT WORLD WAR THREE, RESTORE PEACE IN EUROPE AND IN THE MIDDLE EAST, AND BUILD A GREAT IRON DOME MISSILE DEFENSE SHIELD OVER OUR ENTIRE COUNTRY — ALL MADE IN AMERICA
- END THE WEAPONIZATION OF GOVERNMENT AGAINST THE AMERICAN PEOPLE
- STOP THE MIGRANT CRIME EPIDEMIC, DEMOLISH THE FOREIGN DRUG CARTELS, CRUSH GANG VIOLENCE, AND LOCK UP VIOLENT OFFENDERS
- REBUILD OUR CITIES, INCLUDING WASHINGTON DC, MAKING THEM SAFE, CLEAN, AND BEAUTIFUL AGAIN.
- STRENGTHEN AND MODERNIZE OUR MILITARY, MAKING IT, WITHOUT QUESTION, THE STRONGEST AND MOST POWERFUL IN THE WORLD
- KEEP THE U.S. DOLLAR AS THE WORLD’S RESERVE CURRENCY
- FIGHT FOR AND PROTECT SOCIAL SECURITY AND MEDICARE WITH NO CUTS, INCLUDING NO CHANGES TO THE RETIREMENT AGE
- CANCEL THE ELECTRIC VEHICLE MANDATE AND CUT COSTLY AND BURDENSOME REGULATIONS
- CUT FEDERAL FUNDING FOR ANY SCHOOL PUSHING CRITICAL RACE THEORY, RADICAL GENDER IDEOLOGY, AND OTHER INAPPROPRIATE RACIAL, SEXUAL, OR POLITICAL CONTENT ON OUR CHILDREN
- KEEP MEN OUT OF WOMEN’S SPORTS
- DEPORT PRO-HAMAS RADICALS AND MAKE OUR COLLEGE CAMPUSES SAFE AND PATRIOTIC AGAIN
- SECURE OUR ELECTIONS, INCLUDING SAME DAY VOTING, VOTER IDENTIFICATION, PAPER BALLOTS, AND PROOF OF CITIZENSHIP
- UNITE OUR COUNTRY BY BRINGING IT TO NEW AND RECORD LEVELS OF SUCCESS
This platform needs to be shortened, taken out of all-caps (please!), repeated everywhere, and communicated in soundbites.
Every speech should have five or six memorable soundbites that advance the message and the platform.
All surrogates should be given, as noted above, talking points that advance the message and the platform.
And that is it.
And then you stay disciplined and “on message”, deviating not to the left nor to the right, til election day.
And you clean up the voting process as much as possible. Emerald Robinson asks why anyone should think 2024 won’t be a repeat of 2020, given that the electronic voting issues and absentee ballot issues have not been resolved. She is right.
I have been appalled that almost no Republican lawmakers — except for two in Wyoming, including State Senator Tim Salazar, and Rep Heidi Sampson in Maine — have tried to pass our excellent Election Integrity Bill, a bill we offered the whole country in draft form to anyone, with our lobbying for it for free.
The other hundreds of Republican state senators and Representatives, did NOT pass or even introduce our free, excellent bill.
Do Republicans want to lose?
Do they want to keep losing?
This passivity, forgive me, is astonishing me.
I hear a lot of Republican commentators these days complaining. They complain to me on interviews and on podcasts, about how unfair the legacy media is and how stupid the media coverage is and about how the DNC lies.
And on and on.
All of that is true. I know well the DNC mafia. I know well, DNC lies. I worked for them.
But I also have little patience for all of this whining, and it makes me miss Steve Bannon, imprisoned, as we see now, for good reason; as he was the general of the liberty effort.
As he would have said, No Whining.
Of course legacy media blacks you out. You have a massive independent media universe where the Right is making almost no effort is to elect their own candidate.
Of course the DNC lies and is cynically on the offense, paying off influencers. I could have told you in my sleep their every move in advance. This is the playbook! How can you complain about this if you can’t stay on message for 48 hours?
Why be your own worst enemy?
Of course coverage is stupid. If you show some message discipline and get lots of surrogates, you don’t need to rely on getting past the stupidities of the coverage because you will be reaching the voters yourselves, directly.
I love MAGA.
I love MAGA in many ways.
I think only the joined forces of Trump and RFK Jr can save this country (and thus, can begin to save the word) from murderous globalism.
So much is at stake.
It’s so, so easy to do the right things.
So why not do them?
This is an opportunity for MAGA and Republican supporters of President Trump (and RFK Jr supporters too separately, and someday, I hope, together) to transcend their private wish lists and their personal echo chambers and to truly unite and heal the country.
It takes some maturity.
It takes some discipline.
Will you do it?
Will you save us?
Or will you, rather, choose to fall prey to frat-boy jokes; to all-or-nothing wish lists; to judgmental sectarianism; to insider nudges; and to snarky gossip —
And thus lose it all?
Originally published on Substack.