A Letter From the Transgender Perspective
I’ve been thinking about writing to you for a long time. More and more of us are awake now to the great evil forces that are sweeping much of humanity all over the world. But the prince of darkness is diabolically clever and is manipulating the minds of the awake to turn them into their own little gardens of mass formation psychosis that result in our increasing mistrust, prejudgment, and ostracization of those in the movement who don’t fit into their own digested narratives about who qualifies to be in our movement for the freedom to be true to our own selves and to be good and kind to all. The freedom to have our own ideas but to want our ideas to be tested and challenged and to test others’ ideas and to learn and grow from the diversity of our community. Now I will turn to my own personal perspective, one which I think many others living in today’s world can identify with.
Sadly, this kind of true valuing of and love for each other in all our diversity (and I mean a diversity of ideas and thoughts as well of ethnicity, religion, etc.) is becoming I believe rare. Perhaps I am in a better position than most to sense in my bones the changing pressure of the barometer in society as it happens. You see, I am one of those people who was assigned the wrong gender at birth (At this point, at least 95% of the people I write to who are in the right to be free and good movement would stop reading my letter, conjuring up images planted in their brain of how sick, demented, deranged, perverted, psychotic, mentally unbalanced, and disgusting a person I must be. Like with vacc1ne injured, they will refuse to listen to my story and delegitimize my condition. They will incessantly repeat narratives that there is no biological basis for the trans condition and mock and disparage me (Does this sound familiar? Yes as far as I can see, it is exactly the way those injured by the poisonous shots are being treated). Never mind that there are a host of biological conditions with strong associations with gender identity “deviations”, a topic on which I plan to present a paper at an upcoming scientific meeting. No, they won’t even look at the science, they already know what is true they believe and they’ll only listen to sources that support the narrative that is already frozen in their brains. My friend who is XXY doesn’t have the right to be accepted as a woman. The woman who comes from a family with inherited genetic mosaicism who had her reproductive organs developed enough to give birth to a daughter even though her body is predominantly XY is especially triggering for them: It turns out researchers found genetic mosaicism running through her family for multiple generations. According to them she is a man and has no right to identify as a woman because of her chromosomes, but if she identified as a man she would have no right to do so either because of her female reproductive parts.
I feel increasingly separated from both of the ideological camps which are equally into othering of groups of people who don’t fit in with their set of beliefs that must be accepted without question. Both are into telling other people how to live their lives and attack our bodily autonomy, just in different ways. I, for one, cannot condone those who incessantly call trans people mentally ill, condoners and promoters of pedophilia, perverted, dangerous, etc. Almost everyone who identifies and condemns the corruption of the ruling class (Although our rulers currently predominantly identify on the left, I don’t personally feel they at all represent historically progressive values) is attacking us. The hosts of most of the programs you appear on are incessantly attacking the LGBTQ+ community with the greatest vitriol reserved for those who are trans or nonbinary. They are attempting to deny our lived reality just as much as others are doing so to the vax injured, compassionate doctors and nurses, and other nonconformers to the rules of the tribe.
I am appealing to you to be a voice that stands up against the tyranny of the right just as much as you do the tyranny of the left, and the canceling behavior of the right which, if they are allowed to gain as much power as the left currently has, have shown they will cancel from society certain people like me who dare to live authentically as their true selves. Their thought process parallels that of the left tribe who are currently canceling me for my nonconformist and independent views.
As I write these final words my heart was further broken by just now starting to listen to a broadcast coming from DailyClout entitled “Transgender Ideology: Does it Erase Women?“. I am deeply saddened listening to these two women attack the validity of the identities of transwomen and transmen, repeatedly misgendering people and calling us all a threat to women. I am in shock; I thought you were the only organization I know of that would accept me on their team: A team that is fighting for personal freedom, the right to think independently; and dare I say, the right to live according to our gender identity (which is often shaped by genetic deviations and chemical exposures, especially in utero). Still, I will send this to you now with the hope that you will read this and I will pray that your heart will be open to my words. I fear for my country, and selfishly I fear for myself as well. I now live in a small town where no one knows my background as of yet, but what happens when someone finds out about it one way or another? Moral decay is all over the place and we are increasingly attacking one another in more and more dangerous ways. I hope you will stand up against the attempts to “other” any of our diverse communities, even the lowly and almost subhuman (according to so many) trans people of the world. I and others have no home on the right or left in this country, I pray that hearts will be changed on both sides because they are both I believe equally fighting the demons of darkness egging them on to unfairly discriminate in different ways.
I must finally thank you for all that you have done to fight for humanity and against evil. Please continue with what you do, but consider what I have to say above as you go forward.
2 replies added
Thanks Dena for adding this thoughtful letter, and the DC for posting it. I feel similarly, that there is no longer a right or left that holds compassion and freedom at their core. Those of us who do will meet in the middle, respecting each others’ differences and ways of existing and build a new world.
One thing I would add is that, like the needlework, there appears to be a nefarious agenda that is attacking the bodies of innocent people which in turn co-opts the very genuine experience of trans people. It is rare to hear critique about the pedophiles and pharmaceutical companies who are benefiting from manipulation, instead it is called “the trans agenda” suggesting that it is trans people pushing it. Not looking beyond this click bait headline to who may benefit from ostracizing a highly feared minority pushes one back out to the left / right extremes. This can’t be the way forward.
Trans people have always existed and are such a small percentage of the population, statistically doing very little harm. Big pharma, governments and pedophiles have a lot to answer for, and I hope your letter helps people re-think where they are placing their attention in this issue, like they so easily do with other issues of coercion.
Thank you Anonymous for your very insightful reply. I think what we are seeing manifested in today’s world is that people on all sides are viewing the world as simplistically divided between the good and the evil and of course most people fancy themselves as staunchly on the side of the good. The danger of falling into this trap is expressed so well by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn in “The Gulag Archipelago” (translated from the Russian): “If only it were all so simple! If only there were evil people somewhere insidiously committing evil deeds, and it were necessary only to separate them from the rest of us and destroy them. But the line dividing good and evil cuts through the heart of every human being. And who is willing to destroy a piece of his own heart?” If you will read his works and that of others through such cycles of history you will understand a predictable pattern that occurs in human history when the evil morally bankrupt side of our human nature takes control of the hearts of our elites. The elites become drunk with delusions of grandeur and their supreme confidence in their superiority over the masses. This pattern involves the blossoming of an incessant, relentless drive of the elites to exert their power and control over the common people and promote diminishment of personal autonomy in the name of a so-called common good. This leads to a society that doesn’t value the individual and where personal freedom and independent thinking are viewed as dangerous. The end result is the proliferation of discrimination of the worst kind against minorities and nonconformers of all kinds (and where the discriminators are blaming the discriminated for all their own evils that they have lost all self-awareness of). A feature of this horrendous cycle that keeps repeated itself in human history is that we are all recruited into participating in the evil deeds by a powerful set of incentives and threats. The elite know, consciously or subconsciously that most people, if put under enough pressure, will succumb to the evil pieces of their own hearts.
Now, more directly to your point about the general attack on all sides against the individual which has spread like a virus in our society, and yes, including the so-called “trans agenda”. People are losing their moral compass in this and really virtually all of the current moves to remake society into their own image which they sincerely or insincerely state leads to the collective good. Regarding children, just let them grow up in a world where they are loved and respected as they naturally are, regardless of whether their identity conforms precisely to what others assume them to be. Do not judge people by their appearance, but by the content of their character! Children are living in a world now where increasingly they are being told by people on both sides exactly how they should live and taught to reflexively distrust people on the other side of this or that narrative. One cannot assume either that their parents or guardians are all good and loving and accepting or are all mentally and physically abusing them. I certainly know trans individuals who tried to express to their parents or guardians their very heart-felt and stable views of their own identities from childhood and were repeatedly abused and punished severely largely for doing so. But I believe most parents love their children deeply and the natural bond of love will prevail even though they may not at first understand or easily believe what is going on within their child is the natural expression of their brains and hearts. The great tragedy of today is that people on both sides are with increasing frequency taking absolutist positions and attempting to impose one size fits all solutions on everyone. This is, in my opinion, putting severe pressure on trans- and cisgender children alike and I think must be so confusing to them. What are trans children to think when they are told repeatedly that they are morally defective, mentally ill, and deceived about their own identities? Or that they are told that their parents or guardians do not really love and care about them and should not be trusted?
The value of the individual is inviolate regardless of their personal identity. It does not matter whether a transgender person or a vaccine injured or a person with some particular kind of brain damage is rare. It does not matter whether we have discovered one particular test that will provide an absolute confirmation of who they are (that is really unlikely given the biological complexities of all of these conditions). They are all real and they all deserve to be listened to when they try to tell their stories. None of us should be asked to sacrifice our own personal health or autonomy for the common good. Let us love one another just as we are.